( The following comments refer to Rainbow Smelt as represented
in the lawsuit against the Corps of Engineers by the state of
South Dakota - ed ) ...They (Rainbow Smelt) do not eat ONLY
plankton, they eat NATIVE FISH and are
responsible in large part for the decline of Native Fish in the Missouri
River in the Dakotas.
Rainbow Smelt
- Osmerus mordax
The original geographic range of smelt was along the eastern coast of
North America. Although this species was primarily anadromous, many native
landlocked smelt populations are located along the east coast and in the
St. Lawrence River area.
Early in this century, smelt were introduced into
waters connecting to the Great Lakes, and by the 1930's, smelt had greatly
expanded their geographic range, having spread throughout all of the Great
Lakes; presently smelt are a dominant pelagic species in the Great Lakes.
Since then, this species has invaded many inland lakes of eastern Canada.
Smelt prey heavily on young-of-the-year fish, and their introduction into
lakes has led to major declines of native species, particularly lake
trout,
whitefish and cisco. In addition, the introduction of smelt into lakes
also leads to increased levels of PCB's and mercury in top predators such as
lake trout.
|
|
It is common knowledge among fisheries Biologists, "Big Fish eat Little
Fish".
I believe Stephen Alfred Forbes said it best when doing research in
1908. "Among the enemies of Cyprinidae (Minnows), disclosed by our study of
1,221 Illinois fishes, already referred to, practically all are most
predacious fishes, including the Dogfish, both our common species of
Gar (the Walleyed Pike), both species of Pickerel (one is Northern
Pike), Small and Large Mouth Bass, Yellow Perch, the Mudcat,
crappies, and sunfish, etc."
THAT THIS LIST MIGHT BE CONSIDERABLY ENLARGED BY MORE EXTENSIVE STUDIES OF
THE FOOD FISHES IS BEYOND A DOUBT.
It is safe to say that no fish eating
fish would, if hungry for fish, refuse a minnow of any kind, unless it
seemed too small to be worth the trouble of capturing. It is not too much to
say, consequently, that the number of game fish which any water can maintain
is largely conditioned upon it's permanent stock of minnows".
A personal note: All of the northern basin states have overstocked the Missouri River
lakes with too many game fish. As a result they are eating every
"small" fish
they can find. There is a reason the Walleyes in Lake Oahe are only
1.5
pounds at three years - they are starving.
Hungry fish eat everything in
sight. This includes their own young and the young of NATIVE
FISH. The
Rainbow Smelt are starving too.
This is a quote from Wayne Nelson-Stastny, a Fisheries Biologist
for the SDGF&P Missouri River Fisheries Center,
"Smelt are carnivorous and in Lake Oahe consume mostly zooplankton. However, by weight,
young-of-the-year smelt made up 63% of the bio-mass consumed by adult
smelt in lower Oahe. Combine the high abundance of adult smelt with good
reproduction in those years, and there is strong evidence of adult smelt
cannibalizing young-of-the-year smelt."
Here is another one from Tony
Dean, South Dakota fishing Guru, "predation by a huge Walleye population and Oahe's other
predators is the biggest problem, and with smelt in short supply they are
eating everything in sight. They have decimated PERCH, and Spot tailed
shiners, and have turned to Drum and Small Mouthed Bass."
Does anyone
believe the Smelt who are so hungry they have turned cannibalistic, and starving Walleye are not going to eat every fish in the lake? This includes
Pallid Sturgeons, Sturgeon Chubs, Sicklefin chubs, Blue Sucker,
Sauger, Spoon Bills, and every other fish that is loosing numbers above Gavins
Point.
If ever there was an opportunity to go on the offensive which we have
yet to do, this is it.
It's past time to set the record straight and expose
the "TRIPE" that has been coming from South Dakota, North Dakota, and Montana for what it is,
self-serving non-sense that is killing NATIVE FISH while
padding the pockets
of their fishing industry.
- Capt. Bill Beacom
|